top of page
Search
a fan

Comeback Wins and Blown Leads for losses - 1996-2019

Updated: Feb 10, 2020

"You're losing the game at one point (could be first or 2nd inning) but come from behind and win -or- you're winning the game at one point but end up losing. Which team in the MLB / NL / AL had the BEST improvement between the first half of the season and the second half of the season between 1996 and 2019? A positive value indicates the team did better. A negative value, the team did worse.

If you want to see the significance again of the ZScore and what it can be telling you, please see:https://baseballfan999.wixsite.com/baseballdat/post/what-does-the-zscore-tell-you Most improved Team in 2nd half of season compared to their first half with comeback wins.


Note: this time period spans the same time period that those great Joe Torre Yankee teams as well as some of those great Billy Beane Oakland teams in the 2000-2002 time frame.


From the July to the end of the season

AL:

The best team: Oakland A's ZScore: 1.71

Oakland may have scored higher but you'll notice from the figures below that St. Louis had more volume of comebacks

The worst team: the Seattle Mariners - ZScore: -1.21

NL:

The best team: St. Louis Cardinals ZScore: 1.30

Oakland may have scored higher but you'll notice from the figures below that St. Louis had more volume of comebacks

The worst team: the Milwaukee Brewers - ZScore: -1.45

Comeback win zscore totals comparing first and 2nd half to each other. 1st half (Mar-June) and 2nd (July - End) half side by side. The widest gap where Orange > Blue indicates most improved.



 

The figures based on this time frame 1996-2019

Green = Most improved NL and AL "devil magic" teams in 2nd half of season

Red = Most declined


Second Half Improvement:
    Team  ZScoreTotalImprovement
0   BAL               -0.450906
1   NYA                0.002996
2   BOS               -0.656505
3   HOU                0.254374
4   MIL               -1.452710
5   MIN               -0.650013
6   DET                0.247445
7   CHA               -0.198778
8   CLE                0.841293
9   KCA                0.348911
10  TEX               -0.555080
11  OAK                1.710849
12  CIN               -0.910027
13  SLN                1.297846
14  PIT                0.152291
15  CHN                0.775903
16  SFN               -0.390979
17  SDN               -0.572122
18  LAN                0.332698
19  PHI               -0.206369
20  NYN                0.187170
21  ATL               -0.374929
22  TOR               -1.090997
23  SEA               -1.211893
24  ANA                0.895403
25  WAS                0.541069
26  COL                0.454639
27  MIA                0.072711
28  TBA                0.655052
29  ARI               -0.049342

Total wins and Late Inn rally wins for first half and second half of season
    Team  FirstHalfTotW  FirstHalfRallyW  SecondHalfTotW  SecondHalfRallyW
0   BAL            895              351             901               334
1   NYA           1094              412            1192               454
2   BOS           1066              370            1075               403
3   HOU            954              358            1032               363
4   MIL            936              356             935               333
5   MIN            942              384             965               377
6   DET            882              321             895               328
7   CHA            958              365             962               365
8   CLE            979              340            1063               384
9   KCA            829              332             879               349
10  TEX            994              380             975               360
11  OAK            970              340            1063               398
12  CIN            911              357             945               351
13  SLN           1022              335            1109               387
14  PIT            885              341             887               330
15  CHN            927              325             998               346
16  SFN            997              371            1012               370
17  SDN            912              367             935               329
18  LAN           1033              379            1086               377
19  PHI            914              365            1010               392
20  NYN            956              341             996               343
21  ATL           1056              364            1085               366
22  TOR            951              355             970               359
23  SEA            979              359             946               353
24  ANA           1009              369            1022               394
25  WAS            932              335             957               336
26  COL            915              348             921               378
27  MIA            894              344             914               304
28  TBA            820              296             866               322
29  ARI            888              333             875               304

Total losses and Late Inn losses for first half and second half of season
    Team  FirstHalfTotL  FirstHalfBlownL  SecondHalfTotL  SecondHalfBlownL
0   BAL           1005              393            1088               398
1   NYA            787              287             813               308
2   BOS            841              314             905               368
3   HOU            975              364             927               356
4   MIL            973              346            1043               391
5   MIN            955              351            1026               365
6   DET           1008              392            1099               396
7   CHA            940              386            1028               390
8   CLE            914              337             928               343
9   KCA           1063              397            1113               401
10  TEX            923              358             998               358
11  OAK            956              380             897               357
12  CIN            996              347            1039               382
13  SLN            885              342             871               336
14  PIT           1017              375            1095               363
15  CHN            972              348             991               342
16  SFN            924              348             954               360
17  SDN           1018              359            1024               349
18  LAN            894              318             875               297
19  PHI            992              331             971               361
20  NYN            949              362             986               360
21  ATL            866              300             879               319
22  TOR            979              343             988               395
23  SEA            939              339            1022               387
24  ANA            913              349             943               327
25  WAS            976              373            1021               356
26  COL           1005              365            1049               372
27  MIA           1023              401            1053               366
28  TBA            936              342             940               355
29  ARI            884              351             917               337
   Team  ZScoresRallyWinsFirstHalf  ZScoresRallyWinsSecondHalf
0   BAL                  -0.094892                   -0.810584
1   NYA                   2.661492                    2.984088
2   BOS                   0.763654                    1.371352
3   HOU                   0.221414                    0.106462
4   MIL                   0.131041                   -0.842206
5   MIN                   1.396266                    0.549173
6   DET                  -1.450490                   -1.000318
7   CHA                   0.537721                    0.169706
8   CLE                  -0.591945                    0.770529
9   KCA                  -0.953438                   -0.336250
10  TEX                   1.215520                    0.011595
11  OAK                  -0.591945                    1.213241
12  CIN                   0.176228                   -0.273006
13  SLN                  -0.817878                    0.865396
14  PIT                  -0.546758                   -0.937073
15  CHN                  -1.269744                   -0.431117
16  SFN                   0.808840                    0.327818
17  SDN                   0.628094                   -0.968695
18  LAN                   1.170333                    0.549173
19  PHI                   0.537721                    1.023507
20  NYN                  -0.546758                   -0.525984
21  ATL                   0.492534                    0.201328
22  TOR                   0.085855                   -0.020027
23  SEA                   0.266601                   -0.209761
24  ANA                   0.718467                    1.086752
25  WAS                  -0.817878                   -0.747340
26  COL                  -0.230452                    0.580796
27  MIA                  -0.411198                   -1.759252
28  TBA                  -2.580156                   -1.190051
29  ARI                  -0.908251                   -1.759252

Second Half Won/Loss Spread over First Half Won / Loss spread:
    Team  FirstHalfImprovementZScores  SecondHalfImprovementZScores
0   BAL                    -0.911050                     -1.361957
1   NYA                     2.973584                      2.976580
2   BOS                     1.289487                      0.632982
3   HOU                    -0.102594                      0.151780
4   MIL                     0.232660                     -1.220050
5   MIN                     0.859930                      0.209917
6   DET                    -1.676987                     -1.429542
7   CHA                    -0.392768                     -0.591546
8   CLE                     0.006548                      0.847841
9   KCA                    -1.495954                     -1.147042
10  TEX                     0.604141                      0.049060
11  OAK                    -0.919749                      0.791100
12  CIN                     0.237367                     -0.672660
13  SLN                    -0.232408                      1.065438
14  PIT                    -0.785791                     -0.633500
15  CHN                    -0.624151                      0.151752
16  SFN                     0.583315                      0.192336
17  SDN                     0.241359                     -0.330764
18  LAN                     1.439563                      1.772261
19  PHI                     0.792030                      0.585661
20  NYN                    -0.505748                     -0.318577
21  ATL                     1.433576                      1.058647
22  TOR                     0.271036                     -0.819961
23  SEA                     0.462200                     -0.749692
24  ANA                     0.509275                      1.404678
25  WAS                    -0.900203                     -0.359134
26  COL                    -0.386628                      0.068011
27  MIA                    -1.267130                     -1.194418
28  TBA                    -1.256129                     -0.601077
29  ARI                    -0.478782                     -0.528125
   Team  RallyWinsFirstHalf  BlownLeadsFirstHalf  RallyWinsSecondHalf  \
0   BAL                 351                  393                  334   
1   NYA                 412                  287                  454   
2   BOS                 370                  314                  403   
3   HOU                 358                  364                  363   
4   MIL                 356                  346                  333   
5   MIN                 384                  351                  377   
6   DET                 321                  392                  328   
7   CHA                 365                  386                  365   
8   CLE                 340                  337                  384   
9   KCA                 332                  397                  349   
10  TEX                 380                  358                  360   
11  OAK                 340                  380                  398   
12  CIN                 357                  347                  351   
13  SLN                 335                  342                  387   
14  PIT                 341                  375                  330   
15  CHN                 325                  348                  346   
16  SFN                 371                  348                  370   
17  SDN                 367                  359                  329   
18  LAN                 379                  318                  377   
19  PHI                 365                  331                  392   
20  NYN                 341                  362                  343   
21  ATL                 364                  300                  366   
22  TOR                 355                  343                  359   
23  SEA                 359                  339                  353   
24  ANA                 369                  349                  394   
25  WAS                 335                  373                  336   
26  COL                 348                  365                  378   
27  MIA                 344                  401                  304   
28  TBA                 296                  342                  322   
29  ARI                 333                  351                  304   

    BlownLeadsSecondHalf  
0                    398  
1                    308  
2                    368  
3                    356  
4                    391  
5                    365  
6                    396  
7                    390  
8                    343  
9                    401  
10                   358  
11                   357  
12                   382  
13                   336  
14                   363  
15                   342  
16                   360  
17                   349  
18                   297  
19                   361  
20                   360  
21                   319  
22                   395  
23                   387  
24                   327  
25                   356  
26                   372  
27                   366  
28                   355  
29                   337  
   Team  FirstHalfWPercentTot  SecondHalfWPercentTot
0   BAL              0.512409               0.487591
1   NYA              0.475751               0.524249
2   BOS              0.478655               0.521345
3   HOU              0.496533               0.503467
4   MIL              0.516691               0.483309
5   MIN              0.504599               0.495401
6   DET              0.494607               0.505393
7   CHA              0.500000               0.500000
8   CLE              0.469613               0.530387
9   KCA              0.487518               0.512482
10  TEX              0.513514               0.486486
11  OAK              0.460705               0.539295
12  CIN              0.504237               0.495763
13  SLN              0.463989               0.536011
14  PIT              0.508197               0.491803
15  CHN              0.484352               0.515648
16  SFN              0.500675               0.499325
17  SDN              0.527299               0.472701
18  LAN              0.501323               0.498677
19  PHI              0.482166               0.517834
20  NYN              0.498538               0.501462
21  ATL              0.498630               0.501370
22  TOR              0.497199               0.502801
23  SEA              0.504213               0.495787
24  ANA              0.483617               0.516383
25  WAS              0.499255               0.500745
26  COL              0.479339               0.520661
27  MIA              0.530864               0.469136
28  TBA              0.478964               0.521036
29  ARI              0.522763               0.477237


Here's the input data generated by the custom program designed to extract the scenario.Apr includes March reg season games. Sept includes Oct reg season games.

Team,AprW,AprL,MayW,MayL,JunW,JunL,JulW,JulL,AugW,AugL,SepW,SepL,AprW_LBY5Plus,AprW_LBY4,AprW_LBY3,AprW_LBY2,AprW_LBY1,MayW_LBY5Plus,MayW_LBY4,MayW_LBY3,MayW_LBY2,MayW_LBY1,JunW_LBY5Plus,JunW_LBY4,JunW_LBY3,JunW_LBY2,JunW_LBY1,JulW_LBY5Plus,JulW_LBY4,JulW_LBY3,JulW_LBY2,JulW_LBY1,AugW_LBY5Plus,AugW_LBY4,AugW_LBY3,AugW_LBY2,AugW_LBY1,SepW_LBY5Plus,SepW_LBY4,SepW_LBY3,SepW_LBY2,SepW_LBY1,AprL_WBY5Plus,AprL_WBY4,AprL_WBY3,AprL_WBY2,AprL_WBY1,MayL_WBY5Plus,MayL_WBY4,MayL_WBY3,MayL_WBY2,MayL_WBY1,JunL_WBY5Plus,JunL_WBY4,JunL_WBY3,JunL_WBY2,JunL_WBY1,JulL_WBY5Plus,JulL_WBY4,JulL_WBY3,JulL_WBY2,JulL_WBY1,AugL_WBY5Plus,AugL_WBY4,AugL_WBY3,AugL_WBY2,AugL_WBY1,SepL_WBY5Plus,SepL_WBY4,SepL_WBY3,SepL_WBY2,SepL_WBY1

BAL,295,296,307,354,293,355,284,340,315,365,302,383,5,4,17,42,54,5,10,19,35,47,4,7,14,39,49,5,7,9,24,61,7,6,10,36,51,4,4,21,30,59,6,9,17,29,44,6,5,18,41,79,5,8,16,36,74,3,7,12,37,67,5,4,12,36,72,5,6,19,36,77

NYA,340,245,376,282,378,260,385,240,406,288,401,285,5,4,13,32,65,6,7,16,40,77,4,11,19,35,78,4,2,21,45,83,5,8,17,43,65,4,9,19,34,95,1,7,13,30,51,5,7,9,24,44,3,6,11,32,44,2,1,13,28,50,2,6,12,30,52,6,4,19,23,60

BOS,336,255,378,293,352,293,340,286,375,303,360,316,5,11,19,41,46,7,5,14,39,70,6,4,20,34,49,1,15,19,31,64,6,14,22,37,63,5,10,18,37,61,3,5,16,29,46,3,10,18,29,57,9,5,16,19,49,0,8,13,29,70,4,6,20,42,54,3,2,12,35,70

HOU,291,310,336,345,327,320,318,302,360,320,354,305,4,2,9,30,55,4,7,14,46,68,1,6,12,29,71,2,4,13,22,64,2,4,13,39,71,3,6,19,29,72,2,3,14,31,63,4,6,12,36,68,2,7,20,35,61,1,9,24,27,56,2,9,12,31,67,1,5,12,24,76

MIL,294,304,320,351,322,318,292,349,311,353,332,341,1,5,17,24,63,3,7,24,28,62,3,5,15,43,56,1,8,16,31,51,1,5,11,26,55,4,6,11,34,73,2,5,13,27,62,3,6,11,41,54,4,4,13,22,79,8,8,12,42,66,4,8,15,40,69,3,2,16,27,71

MIN,286,299,327,336,329,320,321,308,323,361,321,357,6,11,12,37,62,7,6,15,34,67,1,3,18,35,70,5,9,17,36,60,4,8,15,31,61,2,5,14,24,86,2,5,10,33,58,5,6,16,35,57,2,5,14,26,77,4,5,7,46,54,3,4,13,33,60,2,10,18,39,67

DET,269,316,310,353,303,339,303,329,299,385,293,385,1,8,12,24,45,7,4,15,28,57,3,3,10,33,71,5,4,15,23,62,4,7,14,28,54,4,10,14,32,52,5,4,12,35,60,3,6,24,37,60,2,8,15,37,84,9,5,13,33,70,8,4,16,29,75,7,4,13,32,78

CHA,295,288,330,339,333,313,297,325,335,355,330,348,4,5,16,37,52,1,4,16,39,68,5,9,13,35,61,5,3,11,41,53,5,4,24,30,65,3,4,17,36,64,2,4,13,28,64,6,6,13,39,68,5,6,20,35,77,1,7,17,34,66,0,7,20,35,73,4,4,16,36,70

CLE,293,284,361,307,325,323,316,310,371,307,376,311,6,3,9,31,39,8,3,21,46,56,4,3,19,27,65,4,5,14,29,66,8,4,16,27,83,2,4,20,40,62,7,5,12,31,44,4,6,11,32,73,8,4,22,23,55,5,6,12,35,54,3,7,18,33,50,2,2,18,37,61

KCA,245,338,281,387,303,338,270,364,298,387,311,362,4,5,11,22,58,4,9,19,32,52,5,6,15,29,61,5,5,9,29,63,1,5,9,24,73,8,3,21,32,62,3,8,17,40,57,9,6,24,40,69,1,10,13,37,63,5,5,26,27,64,8,9,25,37,66,4,8,18,32,67

TEX,305,296,359,309,330,318,291,330,356,328,328,340,3,3,15,28,56,6,7,14,46,71,1,14,16,38,62,4,7,17,38,48,7,9,15,36,59,2,4,20,32,62,5,14,16,29,46,6,5,14,27,60,5,4,18,34,75,7,9,17,35,66,5,7,13,27,59,5,8,19,27,54

OAK,303,309,313,352,354,295,335,287,369,307,359,303,4,7,13,34,53,5,5,7,27,55,4,3,16,31,76,5,10,18,40,72,5,5,15,30,70,5,9,16,32,66,3,5,16,33,60,5,10,19,27,76,4,6,15,32,69,6,3,13,32,70,6,5,13,34,62,1,9,11,37,55

CIN,278,320,328,342,305,334,302,325,325,359,318,355,2,14,12,26,55,3,8,17,39,55,6,8,10,28,74,6,7,16,31,61,5,5,12,30,58,3,9,17,27,64,6,6,16,30,50,5,4,9,39,66,6,9,11,29,61,6,3,23,28,62,2,11,16,39,59,2,9,10,33,79

SLN,341,257,353,312,328,316,346,279,386,294,377,298,4,8,16,30,62,4,4,9,33,63,3,5,10,28,56,5,4,14,39,58,6,5,22,42,63,2,7,14,33,73,1,7,17,30,51,3,6,17,31,59,3,5,15,36,61,5,5,10,35,57,2,6,9,27,49,4,5,13,41,68

PIT,272,316,318,356,295,345,306,320,285,396,296,379,2,3,8,31,56,6,12,16,36,56,2,7,16,32,58,2,4,13,33,68,3,8,6,28,60,2,4,11,22,66,1,6,20,32,58,5,3,12,33,74,9,8,16,39,59,5,2,16,28,59,2,4,17,45,62,5,6,13,30,69

CHN,289,296,324,337,314,339,332,296,326,358,340,337,2,3,20,26,49,2,3,8,25,71,4,2,20,24,66,6,5,15,30,64,3,6,14,22,64,4,6,9,25,73,3,7,12,30,57,2,5,26,42,54,1,6,10,42,51,5,2,9,31,60,6,7,12,32,59,2,5,18,34,60

SFN,315,286,348,322,334,316,313,310,350,330,349,314,4,6,16,38,57,4,4,15,29,74,3,7,24,28,62,0,5,11,34,82,1,7,11,35,65,4,5,12,42,56,7,2,16,25,57,2,6,10,39,60,4,7,11,33,69,4,2,11,27,58,5,8,8,34,75,4,6,15,31,72

SDN,282,331,333,340,297,347,290,331,340,334,305,359,6,4,13,32,55,4,3,13,40,74,6,6,15,28,68,6,3,6,31,57,2,7,10,32,67,6,3,8,31,60,0,5,13,28,70,2,1,10,36,65,3,3,22,39,62,4,3,11,30,69,2,2,10,33,58,2,3,13,36,73

LAN,336,273,363,304,334,317,345,274,379,298,362,303,3,7,18,26,59,1,9,13,30,74,3,7,18,43,68,3,2,15,21,67,4,6,8,38,83,6,3,18,35,68,2,0,18,27,62,2,5,12,32,65,1,5,15,26,46,3,5,5,25,56,1,6,16,20,66,5,3,6,30,50

PHI,288,303,339,329,287,360,328,298,338,334,344,339,6,11,12,24,57,2,6,20,41,64,3,5,18,38,58,4,6,9,40,65,7,6,12,41,66,5,10,16,36,69,7,5,12,27,46,2,8,16,32,60,4,5,17,40,50,4,3,12,28,58,9,5,18,32,77,3,10,13,33,56

NYN,312,280,336,332,308,337,321,302,341,341,334,343,1,3,10,24,74,2,8,9,36,71,3,3,18,28,51,7,4,10,32,56,4,5,10,30,61,4,7,7,37,69,3,8,8,24,57,4,9,10,27,71,1,3,22,41,74,2,5,8,24,64,4,7,13,40,61,2,5,19,31,75

ATL,325,272,383,292,348,302,356,266,372,303,357,310,3,4,10,29,63,5,6,13,35,73,2,6,19,37,59,3,2,10,33,73,2,4,15,28,79,3,5,17,26,66,5,2,12,27,55,1,3,8,35,55,2,6,13,36,40,2,8,8,24,55,2,5,10,30,62,6,4,16,26,61

TOR,281,326,353,329,317,324,297,321,324,347,349,320,2,10,15,31,62,4,7,16,33,74,4,3,16,24,54,4,5,15,24,62,4,3,24,39,56,2,3,19,33,66,5,9,17,38,58,3,5,12,28,65,2,4,16,37,44,6,12,22,30,61,6,13,17,25,68,3,3,26,35,68

SEA,316,290,320,345,343,304,296,330,325,350,325,342,3,8,16,41,60,4,10,16,28,57,4,6,9,33,64,4,2,11,33,68,4,9,13,37,63,3,7,16,31,52,6,6,8,30,54,7,8,14,38,56,4,3,15,25,65,3,10,14,34,71,6,5,22,31,61,5,4,21,27,73

ANA,301,306,357,314,351,293,334,286,340,337,348,320,4,6,12,26,48,7,10,16,35,59,4,12,21,42,67,3,10,17,37,69,6,7,17,32,62,3,7,18,37,69,6,4,14,34,54,3,5,17,48,51,2,8,11,30,62,2,6,10,26,47,8,8,16,24,72,2,4,18,30,54

WAS,288,311,324,348,320,317,277,344,339,344,341,333,8,2,10,26,51,2,5,8,41,69,6,5,11,30,61,1,5,15,21,50,7,12,15,30,51,1,3,20,39,66,4,5,7,31,68,1,8,12,40,72,1,8,12,36,68,6,7,8,27,77,5,4,9,31,74,6,6,10,24,62

COL,294,301,308,362,313,342,276,350,321,359,324,340,1,2,15,39,53,4,6,12,28,61,5,7,15,39,61,9,2,21,22,43,2,8,17,38,77,9,3,16,45,66,1,9,17,28,55,8,11,18,27,65,7,7,21,29,62,3,5,23,25,68,3,5,14,33,63,7,8,17,35,63

MIA,274,323,307,367,313,333,308,314,293,379,313,360,3,3,17,25,53,2,4,22,33,62,6,8,12,34,60,4,5,6,34,59,5,6,8,30,53,3,5,12,29,45,5,8,13,26,66,6,8,21,42,77,2,6,22,31,68,4,4,9,29,57,5,6,7,38,70,2,9,13,47,66

TBA,258,290,284,332,278,314,266,301,314,307,286,332,4,5,10,28,46,2,3,14,29,59,1,3,10,31,51,4,6,9,23,53,3,5,18,31,64,5,3,13,28,57,4,6,10,35,53,7,7,19,32,66,6,9,7,29,52,3,2,13,38,52,5,8,13,36,59,2,12,22,33,57

ARI,290,275,305,310,293,299,269,297,313,304,293,316,3,8,19,26,64,3,4,10,28,61,3,8,13,25,58,3,6,13,18,42,2,5,8,38,55,0,5,18,20,71,2,6,15,34,46,2,5,9,30,81,1,7,13,34,66,2,5,14,31,60,2,7,6,32,64,6,3,17,27,61


19 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page